4.1 Computing a balanced reaction energy at a consistent level
These are unexecuted teaching inputs and starting models. Original diagrams are schematics, not calculated results. Validate version-specific syntax, licensed or authorized data, numerical convergence and the scientific model before using this workflow.
4.1.1 Model, units and provenance
Geometry in Å; electronic energy in hartree; vibrational wavenumbers in cm⁻¹. Check each printed field and keep thermal and standard-state terms distinct.
Shared inputs, conventions and evidence
4.1.2 Unexecuted inputs and explicit deltas
Use the accompanying instructions to identify the parent calculation and placement of every delta; a snippet is not automatically a standalone input. Preserve all blank-line and file-provenance requirements.
4.1.2.1 Input block 1
%chk=case13_ethene.chk
%mem=4GB
%nprocshared=2
#p B3LYP/6-31G(d) Opt=(Tight,CalcFC) Freq
SCF=Tight Integral=UltraFine Temperature=298.15 Pressure=1.0
Ethene for balanced hydrogenation
0 1
C -0.670000 0.000000 0.000000
C 0.670000 0.000000 0.000000
H -1.230000 0.930000 0.000000
H -1.230000 -0.930000 0.000000
H 1.230000 0.930000 0.000000
H 1.230000 -0.930000 0.000000
4.1.2.2 Input block 2
%chk=case13_hydrogen.chk
%mem=4GB
%nprocshared=2
#p B3LYP/6-31G(d) Opt=(Tight,CalcFC) Freq
SCF=Tight Integral=UltraFine Temperature=298.15 Pressure=1.0
Hydrogen for balanced hydrogenation
0 1
H 0.000000 0.000000 -0.370000
H 0.000000 0.000000 0.370000
4.1.2.3 Input block 3
%chk=case13_ethane.chk
%mem=4GB
%nprocshared=2
#p B3LYP/6-31G(d) Opt=(Tight,CalcFC) Freq
SCF=Tight Integral=UltraFine Temperature=298.15 Pressure=1.0
Ethane for balanced hydrogenation
0 1
C -0.770000 0.000000 0.000000
C 0.770000 0.000000 0.000000
H -1.135000 1.030000 0.000000
H -1.135000 -0.515000 0.892000
H -1.135000 -0.515000 -0.892000
H 1.135000 0.515000 0.892000
H 1.135000 -1.030000 0.000000
H 1.135000 0.515000 -0.892000
4.1.3 Worked investigation
4.1.3.1 Question and intuition
Is ethane more stable than ethene? Comparing their raw total energies cannot answer that question because the molecules contain different numbers of hydrogen atoms and electrons. A meaningful energetic comparison needs a balanced reaction: C2H4(g) + H2(g) → C2H6(g). The hydrogen molecule supplies the missing atoms and their energy reference. This case teaches the accounting for reaction electronic energy, enthalpy, and Gibbs energy. It does not calculate a catalyst, a hydrogenation mechanism, or a transition-state barrier.
Prerequisites are minimum verification from Case 10 and correction accounting from Case 11. All three species are neutral singlets at the chosen closed-shell model. Each species needs its own isolated-molecule calculation; putting ethene and H2 into one input creates a different physical object, such as an interacting encounter complex, rather than automatically producing the sum of infinitely separated reactants. Keep the gas-phase standard state the same for all jobs.
4.1.3.2 Three complete inputs
Run these as three separate files. The coordinates are original approximate starting geometries. Resource directives request Gaussian's use of memory/cores; the cluster scheduler must separately allocate compatible resources.
See input block 1 above.
See input block 2 above.
See input block 3 above.
4.1.3.3 Workflow
- Balance elements, charge, and the chosen electronic-state description before running anything. List stoichiometric coefficients −1 for ethene, −1 for H2, and +1 for ethane. Confirm that the species on both sides contain two carbons and six hydrogens in total.
- Run and validate all three minima. Nonlinear ethene and ethane have 12 and 18 internal modes respectively; linear H2 has one. Check the ethane torsion visually to ensure the final structure is a minimum rather than an eclipsed saddle.
- Build an energy ledger with Eelec, Hcorr, Gcorr, H, G, imaginary-mode count, temperature, pressure, method, and basis for every species. A missing hydrogen result leaves the reaction calculation incomplete even if both carbon-containing jobs have finished.
- Compute ΔE = Eethane − Eethene − EH2. Apply exactly the same stoichiometric expression to H and G for ΔH and ΔG. Convert only the resulting differences from hartree into kJ mol−1 or kcal mol−1, retaining adequate digits before subtraction.
- Distinguish thermodynamic favorability from rate. A negative reaction Gibbs energy does not imply barrierless reaction or rapid conversion without a catalyst. Qualitatively, alkene hydrogenation is expected to be exothermic, but the teaching level's calculated value must be reported only after the jobs complete.
- Test basis sensitivity by repeating all three calculations at one larger basis, using new checkpoint names. Alternatively, do the same higher-level single point for all species and combine each with its own lower-level thermal correction; label this composite protocol explicitly rather than presenting it as a fully higher-level optimization/frequency result.
4.1.3.4 Checks and scientific limits
Basis consistency means comparable treatment for every term, not identical numerical basis-function counts for chemically different molecules. If a method/basis is changed, recompute every affected species. Never “improve” only the product by using a larger basis and then subtract unchanged reactant energies. For a two-level protocol, write Gi ≈ Ehigh,i + (Glow,i − Elow,i). Its credibility depends on the validity of the lower-level structures and thermal corrections as well as the higher-level energy calculation.
The reaction changes the number of ideal-gas molecules, so translational entropy and standard-state choices matter. For converting all species from 1 atm to 1 M, Δν = −1 and the standard-state term does not cancel. Ethane also contains a low-frequency internal rotor; blindly trusting harmonic entropy can conceal a significant approximation. This is a prompt to assess rotor or quasi-harmonic treatments in advanced work, not permission to discard inconvenient modes selectively.
EN exercise: Create a deliberately inconsistent ledger in which only ethane uses the larger basis. Explain why any apparent agreement with an experimental heat of hydrogenation is not evidence of a sound calculation. Then repair the ledger and identify which experimental conditions must match before comparing ΔH values.
4.1.4 Related calculations
- 3.4 Comparing gas phase and SMD solution consistently
- 4.2 Finding the ammonia inversion transition state