Skip to content

5.2 Isotopes change nuclear motion and thermochemistry

These are unexecuted teaching inputs and starting models. Original diagrams are schematics, not calculated results. Validate version-specific syntax, licensed or authorized data, numerical convergence and the scientific model before using this workflow.

5.2.1 Model, units and provenance

Geometry in Å; electronic energy in hartree; vibrational wavenumbers in cm⁻¹. Check each printed field and keep thermal and standard-state terms distinct.

Shared inputs, conventions and evidence

Original schematic: Isotopes change nuclear motion and thermochemistry. No numerical results are claimed.
Original schematic: Isotopes change nuclear motion and thermochemistry. No numerical results are claimed.

5.2.2 Unexecuted inputs and explicit deltas

Use the accompanying instructions to identify the parent calculation and placement of every delta; a snippet is not automatically a standalone input. Preserve all blank-line and file-provenance requirements.

5.2.2.1 Input block 1

%oldchk=water17.chk
%chk=water18_d2o.chk
%mem=2GB
%nprocshared=2
#p B3LYP/6-31+G(d,p) Freq=(ReadFC,ReadIsotopes)
   Geom=AllCheck Guess=Read

298.15 1.0 1.0
16
2
2

5.2.3 Worked investigation

5.2.3.1 Question, intuition, and prerequisites

What changes when H₂O becomes D₂O if the electrons see the same nuclear charges? Within the ordinary Born–Oppenheimer harmonic model, the electronic potential and Cartesian force constants can be reused; the masses change the mass-weighted vibration problem. Imagine replacing small masses on the same springs with heavier ones. Frequencies generally decrease, but a polyatomic molecule does not obey one universal factor. Prerequisite: the converged water17.chk, including its Hessian, with atom order O, H, H. Do not use a checkpoint that contains only an optimization and no computed force constants.

5.2.3.2 Exact checkpoint delta

See input block 1 above.

The first extra line is temperature in kelvin, pressure in atmospheres, and the thermochemical frequency scale factor. The remaining lines specify isotope mass numbers in the original atom order; integer 2 selects the tabulated deuterium isotopic mass rather than a mass of exactly 2.000000 u. %oldchk preserves the original file by copying its data into a differently named working checkpoint. There is no title or 0 1 line after the route because Geom=AllCheck supplies those sections. This block deliberately does not request new Raman derivatives; the target is isotope frequency/thermochemistry reanalysis.

5.2.3.3 Numbered workflow

  1. From Case 17 record the three H₂O frequencies, electronic energy, zero-point correction, thermal corrections to enthalpy and Gibbs energy, temperature, pressure, and masses.
  2. Run the D₂O reanalysis. Confirm the printed masses correspond to one oxygen and two deuterium atoms, and check that the atom count and geometry have not changed.
  3. Match H₂O and D₂O modes by displacement character. Record the ratio for each corresponding mode; do not merely compare the first line in two arbitrarily sorted tables.
  4. Create water18_hdo.gjf by copying the entire input, changing the working checkpoint to water18_hdo.chk, and replacing the three isotope lines with 16, 1, 2. The temperature/pressure/scale line stays unchanged.
  5. Compare the printed rotational symmetry numbers. HDO loses the H-exchange symmetry of H₂O/D₂O, which matters to rotational entropy. Report frequencies and thermochemistry separately.
  6. For a temperature exercise, copy the D₂O input to a new filename/checkpoint and change only 298.15 to 350.0. Keep the same pressure and masses.

5.2.3.4 Read and check

For an isolated two-body O–H stretching model, use \(\nu\propto1/\sqrt{\mu}\), with \(\mu=m_1m_2/(m_1+m_2)\). Using integer masses only for this back-of-the-envelope calculation gives νOD/νOH ≈ √[(16/17)/(32/18)] ≈ 0.728. Real water modes couple several coordinates, so 0.728 is a reasoning aid, not a required exact result. D₂O should retain three vibrational modes; deuteration is not the removal of a degree of freedom. Its vibrational zero-point energy should decrease in this fixed-potential harmonic comparison.

A changed Sum of electronic and thermal Free Energies does not mean the electronic energy changed. Separate the electronic baseline, ZPE, and thermal/entropy terms. Frequencies are temperature independent in this harmonic reanalysis, whereas partition-function contributions change with temperature. These are ideal-gas rigid-rotor/harmonic-oscillator quantities at the stated pressure, not automatically solution free energies. The isotope exchange reaction H₂O + D₂O ⇌ 2HDO is atom-balanced; “D₂O minus H₂O” alone is not a complete chemical reaction. Nuclear-spin statistical weights, anharmonic isotope effects, and vibrationally averaged geometry require additional treatment.

5.2.3.5 Exercise

EN exercise: Calculate 2G(HDO)−G(H₂O)−G(D₂O) using a consistent temperature, pressure, method, and scale factor. State which electronic contributions cancel within this model. Explain why ignoring the HDO rotational symmetry change can distort the entropy comparison.

5.2.5 Sources and further reading