5.2 Isotopes change nuclear motion and thermochemistry
These are unexecuted teaching inputs and starting models. Original diagrams are schematics, not calculated results. Validate version-specific syntax, licensed or authorized data, numerical convergence and the scientific model before using this workflow.
5.2.1 Model, units and provenance
Geometry in Å; electronic energy in hartree; vibrational wavenumbers in cm⁻¹. Check each printed field and keep thermal and standard-state terms distinct.
Shared inputs, conventions and evidence
5.2.2 Unexecuted inputs and explicit deltas
Use the accompanying instructions to identify the parent calculation and placement of every delta; a snippet is not automatically a standalone input. Preserve all blank-line and file-provenance requirements.
5.2.2.1 Input block 1
%oldchk=water17.chk
%chk=water18_d2o.chk
%mem=2GB
%nprocshared=2
#p B3LYP/6-31+G(d,p) Freq=(ReadFC,ReadIsotopes)
Geom=AllCheck Guess=Read
298.15 1.0 1.0
16
2
2
5.2.3 Worked investigation
5.2.3.1 Question, intuition, and prerequisites
What changes when H₂O becomes D₂O if the electrons see the same nuclear charges? Within the ordinary Born–Oppenheimer harmonic model, the electronic potential and Cartesian force constants can be reused; the masses change the mass-weighted vibration problem. Imagine replacing small masses on the same springs with heavier ones. Frequencies generally decrease, but a polyatomic molecule does not obey one universal factor. Prerequisite: the converged water17.chk, including its Hessian, with atom order O, H, H. Do not use a checkpoint that contains only an optimization and no computed force constants.
5.2.3.2 Exact checkpoint delta
See input block 1 above.
The first extra line is temperature in kelvin, pressure in atmospheres, and the thermochemical frequency scale factor. The remaining lines specify isotope mass numbers in the original atom order; integer 2 selects the tabulated deuterium isotopic mass rather than a mass of exactly 2.000000 u. %oldchk preserves the original file by copying its data into a differently named working checkpoint. There is no title or 0 1 line after the route because Geom=AllCheck supplies those sections. This block deliberately does not request new Raman derivatives; the target is isotope frequency/thermochemistry reanalysis.
5.2.3.3 Numbered workflow
- From Case 17 record the three H₂O frequencies, electronic energy, zero-point correction, thermal corrections to enthalpy and Gibbs energy, temperature, pressure, and masses.
- Run the D₂O reanalysis. Confirm the printed masses correspond to one oxygen and two deuterium atoms, and check that the atom count and geometry have not changed.
- Match H₂O and D₂O modes by displacement character. Record the ratio for each corresponding mode; do not merely compare the first line in two arbitrarily sorted tables.
- Create
water18_hdo.gjfby copying the entire input, changing the working checkpoint towater18_hdo.chk, and replacing the three isotope lines with16,1,2. The temperature/pressure/scale line stays unchanged. - Compare the printed rotational symmetry numbers. HDO loses the H-exchange symmetry of H₂O/D₂O, which matters to rotational entropy. Report frequencies and thermochemistry separately.
- For a temperature exercise, copy the D₂O input to a new filename/checkpoint and change only 298.15 to 350.0. Keep the same pressure and masses.
5.2.3.4 Read and check
For an isolated two-body O–H stretching model, use \(\nu\propto1/\sqrt{\mu}\), with \(\mu=m_1m_2/(m_1+m_2)\). Using integer masses only for this back-of-the-envelope calculation gives νOD/νOH ≈ √[(16/17)/(32/18)] ≈ 0.728. Real water modes couple several coordinates, so 0.728 is a reasoning aid, not a required exact result. D₂O should retain three vibrational modes; deuteration is not the removal of a degree of freedom. Its vibrational zero-point energy should decrease in this fixed-potential harmonic comparison.
A changed Sum of electronic and thermal Free Energies does not mean the electronic energy changed. Separate the electronic baseline, ZPE, and thermal/entropy terms. Frequencies are temperature independent in this harmonic reanalysis, whereas partition-function contributions change with temperature. These are ideal-gas rigid-rotor/harmonic-oscillator quantities at the stated pressure, not automatically solution free energies. The isotope exchange reaction H₂O + D₂O ⇌ 2HDO is atom-balanced; “D₂O minus H₂O” alone is not a complete chemical reaction. Nuclear-spin statistical weights, anharmonic isotope effects, and vibrationally averaged geometry require additional treatment.
5.2.3.5 Exercise
EN exercise: Calculate 2G(HDO)−G(H₂O)−G(D₂O) using a consistent temperature, pressure, method, and scale factor. State which electronic contributions cancel within this model. Explain why ignoring the HDO rotational symmetry change can distort the entropy comparison.