6.3 Water-dimer interaction energy and BSSE
These are unexecuted teaching inputs and starting models. Original diagrams are schematics, not calculated results. Validate version-specific syntax, licensed or authorized data, numerical convergence and the scientific model before using this workflow.
6.3.1 Model, units and provenance
Geometry in Å; electronic energy in hartree; vibrational wavenumbers in cm⁻¹. Check each printed field and keep thermal and standard-state terms distinct.
Shared inputs, conventions and evidence
6.3.2 Unexecuted inputs and explicit deltas
Use the accompanying instructions to identify the parent calculation and placement of every delta; a snippet is not automatically a standalone input. Preserve all blank-line and file-provenance requirements.
6.3.2.1 Input block 1
%chk=water_dimer23_cp.chk
%mem=2GB
%nprocshared=2
#p wB97XD/aug-cc-pVDZ Counterpoise=2
SCF=(Tight,XQC) Int=UltraFine NoSymm
Neutral water dimer: fixed-geometry counterpoise demonstration
0 1 0 1 0 1
O(Fragment=1) 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000
H(Fragment=1) 0.758000 0.000000 -0.586000
H(Fragment=1) -0.758000 0.000000 -0.586000
O(Fragment=2) 0.000000 0.000000 2.900000
H(Fragment=2) 0.000000 0.000000 1.940000
H(Fragment=2) 0.929000 0.000000 3.140000
6.3.3 Worked investigation
6.3.3.1 Question, intuition, and prerequisites
Why can a small basis make two molecules look too strongly bound? In a dimer, each monomer can borrow the partner's basis functions. Comparing that enlarged description with isolated monomers in their smaller own bases gives an unbalanced comparison. Counterpoise evaluates each frozen monomer in the full dimer basis using ghost centers. This removes a particular basis imbalance; it does not repair every error in an interaction energy. Prerequisites: total-energy differences, fragment charge/multiplicity, and the distinction between a fixed-geometry interaction energy and a relaxed binding energy.
6.3.3.2 Complete fixed-geometry input
See input block 1 above.
The charge/multiplicity line specifies whole dimer 0 1, fragment 1 0 1, fragment 2 0 1. Every atom belongs to one of the two fragments. The donor hydrogen points approximately toward the acceptor oxygen. This supplied structure is a teaching geometry, not a claimed optimized minimum. wB97XD already contains its defined empirical dispersion treatment; do not casually add another dispersion correction. The example is gas phase: the documented counterpoise implementation is not combined with SCRF here.
6.3.3.3 Numbered workflow
- Display the geometry with fragment colors. Confirm O···O = 2.90 Å and verify that neither fragment accidentally contains three hydrogens or a missing oxygen.
- Run the job and check convergence for the full complex and fragment subcalculations. A final summary does not excuse an earlier SCF failure.
- Extract the reported counterpoise-corrected energy, BSSE energy, fragment sum, and raw/corrected complexation energies. Record units beside each value; summary energy lines do not all have the same units.
- Reconstruct the definitions below and check the sign convention. Use the fragment energies at the geometry they have in the dimer, not separately optimized water energies, for the fixed-geometry interaction comparison.
- To test basis dependence, repeat the identical geometry with
6-31G(d)and a new checkpoint, changing only the basis. Compare raw and CP-corrected values and the size of BSSE; do not select whichever number looks closest to an expectation. - Only as a separate extension, optimize the dimer and isolated monomers consistently, verify minima, and explicitly include monomer deformation and any ZPE/thermal terms required by the quantity being reported.
6.3.3.4 Read and check
Let EAB^AB mean dimer energy in the dimer basis, EA^A the frozen monomer A in its own basis, and EA^AB the same monomer in the dimer basis. Then \(\Delta E_{\mathrm{raw}}=E_{AB}^{AB}-E_A^A-E_B^B\), while \(\Delta E_{\mathrm{CP}}=E_{AB}^{AB}-E_A^{AB}-E_B^{AB}\). The usual BSSE correction is \(\Delta E_{\mathrm{CP}}-\Delta E_{\mathrm{raw}}\), generally positive for this well-behaved variational fixed-geometry comparison. Negative interaction energy denotes stabilization under this convention. A “counterpoise corrected total energy” is not itself the interaction energy; the appropriate fragment reference still matters.
Arithmetic example only: raw −5.0 kcal mol⁻¹ plus a +1.0 kcal mol⁻¹ BSSE correction gives −4.0 kcal mol⁻¹. This is invented, not the job's result. Use \(1\;E_h\approx627.5095\;\mathrm{kcal\,mol^{-1}}\approx2625.50\;\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\); do not subtract values already converted to different units. A water-dimer interaction should be on the scale of a few kcal mol⁻¹, not hundreds. If a small-basis correction reverses the physical interpretation, report basis inadequacy rather than treating CP as a universal cure.
A relaxed binding energy additionally includes monomer deformation. A binding free energy additionally requires a consistent statistical-mechanical and standard-state treatment, with care for soft intermolecular modes. CP does not supply missing dispersion, solvent physics, or anharmonicity. Counterpoise jobs are specialized multi-calculation jobs; use a separate ordinary calculation if molecular orbitals are needed for visualization.
6.3.3.5 Exercise
EN exercise: Move all three atoms of fragment 2 by +1.00 Å along z, preserving its internal geometry, and rerun with a new checkpoint. How do the raw interaction and BSSE change as the waters separate? Explain why this is a rigid-distance comparison, not a relaxed dissociation curve.
6.3.4 Related calculations
- 6.2 Populations, orbitals, and density cubes
- 6.4 Open-shell O₂: SCF convergence, stability, and spin